Greenwashing Tyranny at COP27

Opinion piece

Taqadum Alkhatib


Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi has been trying to use the United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP27), which started this week in Sharm El-Sheikh, to position Egypt as a global leader in sustainability, touting various environmental initiatives. And to make the most of the opportunity, his autocratic regime has been exploiting the gathering to greenwash its poor human-rights record and repressive tactics.

Egypt’s Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry, who is also COP27’s president-designate, the importance of civil society in “holding companies and governments to account, guarding against greenwashing, and ensuring a just transition” to renewable energy. But, as far as Egypt itself is concerned, that is nothing more than propaganda. In reality, the country’s civil-society groups are facing an unprecedented government crackdown.

Since el-Sisi seized power in 2014, following a military coup the previous year, his regime has run roughshod over basic components of governance such as political parties, parliament, and the constitution. The regime has persecutedactivists, labeled opposition groups terrorist organizations, and relied on military intelligence and other national-security bodies – headed by members of his own family – to consolidate power. Civil-society organizations have been crippled by draconian laws prohibiting NGOs from engaging in public affairs.

According to Human Rights Watch, the authorities have frozen the assets of seven prominent human-rights organizations and forced many others to close. Officials have also dissolved more than 2,000 charity organizations, seized their assets over alleged links to the now-banned Muslim Brotherhood, and expanded the crackdown to include environmental activists. This non-stop assault on NGOs and their staff has severely shrunk what was once a vibrant public sphere, even during the three decades of Hosni Mubarak’s dictatorship.

El-Sisi maintains an iron grip on power by controlling Egypt’s security apparatus. In 2018, he appointed his then-chief of staff, Abbas Kamel, to lead Egypt’s General Intelligence Service and made his son Mahmoud the GIS’s deputy head. Since then, the intelligence establishment has been controlling key institutions behind the scenes. It has taken over private media companies, merged them under the holding company United Media Services, and turned them into propaganda outlets glorifying el-Sisi as Egypt’s “guardian” and calling on Egyptians to support their leader’s “war on terror” in the Sinai Peninsula.

The GIS’s primary objective has always been to repress any hint of civil unrest or popular uprising. To this end, the regime introduced two major reforms. In November 2013, it enacted the protest law, which requires organizers to provide advance notice of their intention to hold protests, bans unauthorized gatherings of over ten people, restricts where protests can take place, and carries penalties of up to five years in prison. Participating in peaceful demonstrations also carries a fine of up to 100,000 Egyptian pounds ($4,100). Two years later, in August 2015, the regime enacted an anti-terrorism law that vaguely defines what constitutes terrorist “entities” and includes a provision criminalizing the dissemination of “false” reports on terrorist attacks – that is, any information not released by the government.

In addition, the regime has been uprooting trees and razing green spaces, particularly in Cairo, supposedly to build new roads and bridges as part of a new urban development drive. In reality, the main reason for the regime’s landscaping projects is to make the public sphere inhospitable to any political gathering that might evolve into a spontaneous mass uprising.

The GIS wields de facto control over every political event in Egypt, from parliamentary elections and constitutional referenda to the passage of new legislation. And it is the body overseeing COP27 as well. By directly managing the conference’s registry system, Egypt’s intelligence apparatus has excluded critical voices and ensured that only pro-government NGOs could register. Security forces have reportedly arrested dozens of activists – including an Indian activist who led a march from Cairo to Sharm El-Sheikh to raise awareness of climate change – to thwart any attempt to stage protests during the two-week gathering.

More than 11 years after the Tahrir Square uprising that toppled Mubarak’s regime, and in the eight years since the military coup that removed the Muslim Brotherhood from power, el-Sisi has cemented his grip on Egypt. But his tactics have deepened the rift between the country’s rival factions, fueling political instability.

The world leaders who have gathered in Sharm El-Sheikh must not lose sight of the brutality of el-Sisi’s regime. A dictatorship teetering on the edge of political turmoil is hardly an appropriate location for COP27 – or for any gathering whose stated goal is to realize a better future for humanity.

originally published on:

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Related Documents

Joint statement: Egyptian and international civil society organizations call for Badr Mohamed’s immediate release

The Egyptian authorities must immediately release Badr Mohamed, who was unjustly convicted in  January 2023 in connection to protests and sentenced to five years in prison after a grossly unfair  trial, said the undersigned civil society organizations.   Badr Mohamed was first arrested on 16 August 2013, when he was just 17 years old, during the  Ramsis Square protests in Cairo; where security forces used unlawful lethal force to disperse   protesters leading to at least 97 deaths. While he was released on bail after three months, he was  later convicted and sentenced to five years’ imprisonment in absentia in August 2017 in  connection to the Ramsis Square protests on charges of participation in an illegal gathering and  engaging in violence. He was re-arrested in May 2020, and retried on the same charges.    On 12 January 2023, Badr Mohamed was convicted and sentenced to five years in prison  following grossly unfair retrial in front of a terrorism circuit of the Cairo Criminal Court. He was  denied the rights to adequate defence, to equality of arms, and to cross-examine witnesses against  him and to call witnesses on his behalf. During the trial hearings, Badr Mohamed was kept inside a  glass cage where he could not fully observe, hear, or speak during proceedings. He was banned  from communicating with his lawyer privately through the pre-trial and trial phases.  Badr Mohamed missed the birth of his daughter Amina who has turned three on 16 January 2024.  In a letter written to his daughter from prison in July 2022, he expresses his frustration at not being  able to watch her grow: “Mama…Baba (father in Arabic), how beautiful are these words. How  sweet is your smile Amina, and how hard it is for your Baba to watch you grow out of a cage!  How hard it is, and for how long my heart can take it? The few minutes we spend together are so